This is from an amazing column by Bill Duryea in the St. Pete Times April 20, 2003. We should be careful not to let times like this happen again.
The Death of Dissent.April 10: The National Baseball Hall of Fame cancels an event commemorating the 15th anniversary of the movie Bull Durham, saying the vocal antiwar stance of two of its stars, Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon, "ultimately could put our troops in more danger."
I believe shortly before that the Tampa United Way cancelled an appearance by Sarandon because it might upset people because of her anti-war outspokenness. Yes, I found it. It was March 28, 2003.
The United Way group in Tampa Bay, Florida, had invited the actress, who has spoken out against the war in Iraq, to an event on women and volunteering to be held on 11 April.
But the group, which promotes community action and volunteering schemes, had begun to receive complaints about her involvement.
United Way of Tampa Bay chairwoman Robin Carson said the event had the potential to become "divisive".
"The focus of our whole meeting had shifted to whether or not we were creating a political platform for Susan Sarandon," she said.
"That is not our purpose. That's not what we're about."
BBC NewsBack to the St Pete Times column.
The Dixie Chicks say they're embarrassed to come from the same state as the president and a nationwide boycott of their music is organized. John Kerry, a Democratic senator from Massachusetts and a decorated Vietnam veteran, calls for "regime change" in the White House and he is labeled a traitor. A Lutheran minister who dared to criticize the war in a California town with a large population of U.S. Marines is heckled by townspeople; "Why don't you leave America now!" one sign reads.
..."But then Maher offered this take on the hijackers: "We have been the cowards, lobbing cruise missiles from 2,000 miles away. That's cowardly. Staying in the airplane when it hits the building --say what you want about it, it's not cowardly."
..."Maher apologized, but his show was canceled several months later. By that time, the public had already identified a new, and entirely contextual, standard for acceptable dissent. Call it the "Yes, but" standard -- "Yes, I believe in free speech, but now's not a good time."
Times are different now, we have a brilliant, charismatic president with a sense of humor. We are very lucky.
There is never a time though for the "yes, I believe in free speech..but now's not a good time" standard.